That House Sitting on the Market Could Be Your Best Shot at a Deal in Sioux Falls, SD

Author Amy Stockberger | Founder, Amy Stockberger Real Estate | Creator, Lifetime Home Support™ Academy | Ranked the #1 Real Estate Team in South Dakota since 2017 and #33 in the Nation by Real Trends

 

Open up a home search in Sioux Falls, SD and you will see them: homes that have been sitting on the market for two months, three months, or sometimes even longer.

Most buyers scroll right past those listings because they assume something must be wrong with the house. But that mindset could be costing you. In today’s market, a home that has been sitting may actually be one of your best opportunities to negotiate a better deal.

If affordability has been your biggest hurdle to buying a home in Sioux Falls, SD, one smart move is to look beyond the newest listings and ask your agent to show you the homes that have been on the market the longest.

Why This Matters in Sioux Falls, SD

In a market like Sioux Falls, SD, buyers often focus heavily on new listings because they feel fresh, exciting, and competitive. But new listings usually attract the most attention, which can limit your negotiating power.

Homes that have been sitting longer may tell a different story.

Sometimes the original asking price was too aggressive. Sometimes the photos did not show the property well. Sometimes the home got buried because there are several similar homes for sale in that price range, neighborhood, or school district.

That does not automatically mean the home is a bad option. It may simply mean the seller is more motivated now than they were when the property first hit the market.

For buyers looking in areas around Sioux Falls, Harrisburg, Brandon, Tea, Hartford, or other nearby communities, lingering listings can create real opportunity if you know how to evaluate them correctly.

Where Some Buyers Are Finding Better Deals

One of the clearest signals of seller motivation is time on market. The longer a property sits, the more likely a seller may be willing to reconsider price, terms, repairs, closing costs, or other concessions.

National housing data continues to show that price reductions and days on market matter. Realtor.com tracks price decrease counts as part of its housing data, and FRED’s national housing inventory data showed the median days on market at 52 days in May 2026.

That matters because buyers who only look at brand-new listings may be missing homes where the seller is already feeling pressure.

If you are trying to buy a home in Sioux Falls, SD and monthly payment is your top concern, ask your agent to sort listings from oldest to newest. Your best-fit home may already be on the market. It may just be further down the search results than you expected.

Lingering Does Not Always Mean Something Is Wrong

It is natural to wonder why a home has not sold yet. But a lingering listing does not automatically mean there is a major issue.

Common reasons a home may sit include:

The asking price started too high.
Some sellers price based on what they hope to get instead of what the market is currently supporting. After several weeks without strong activity, they may become more realistic.

The home did not show well online.
Photos, staging, lighting, listing copy, and marketing matter. A good home can be overlooked if the online presentation is weak.

There is more competition in that segment.
If several homes are available in a similar price range, neighborhood, or layout, even a solid property can get buried.

The seller missed the strongest launch window.
The first few weeks on market usually create the most visibility. If the property did not capture attention early, it may need a pricing or marketing reset.

None of these are automatic dealbreakers.

A thorough inspection can help uncover any real issues. If something does come up, that information gives you leverage. It does not always mean you should walk away.

How To Turn a Lingering Listing into a Win

The right strategy can turn a stale listing into a smart purchase. Here are the main levers buyers should consider.

Tip 1: Study Comparable Sales Before Making an Offer

Before writing an offer, compare the home to similar properties that recently sold in Sioux Falls, SD and the surrounding area.

Look at:

Price per square foot
Condition
Location
Updates
Days on market
Seller concessions
Recent price reductions

If the home is overpriced compared to recent sales, coming in below asking price may be completely reasonable.

Tip 2: Use Seller Motivation Strategically

A seller whose home has been sitting may be more open to negotiation than a seller with a brand-new listing.

That could create room to ask for:

A lower purchase price
Closing cost assistance
Repair credits
A home warranty
A mortgage rate buydown
Flexible closing terms
Inspection-related repairs

For first-time buyers in Sioux Falls, SD, these concessions can make a meaningful difference in upfront cash needed and monthly affordability.

Tip 3: Do Not Skip the Inspection

A lingering listing should be evaluated carefully, not emotionally dismissed.

The inspection helps separate real problems from assumptions. If the inspection shows the home is structurally sound and the needed updates are manageable, you may have found a strong opportunity.

If larger issues appear, your agent can help you decide whether to negotiate, request repairs, ask for credits, or move on.

Tip 4: Look Beyond the Photos

Some homes sit because they were not marketed well. That does not mean the house itself lacks potential.

A home with weak photos, outdated decor, or poor staging may still have strong bones, a great location, or valuable features. Buyers who can look past cosmetic issues often find better opportunities than buyers who only chase polished listings.

Tip 5: Work With a Local Agent Who Knows the Difference

Not every stale listing is a deal. Some are overpriced for a reason. Some need more work than they are worth. Others are genuine opportunities hiding in plain sight.

A local agent can help you separate the homes worth a second look from the ones that should stay off your list.

How Amy Stockberger Real Estate Can Help

At Amy Stockberger Real Estate, we help buyers look beyond the surface so they can make smart, confident decisions in the Sioux Falls, SD market.

Our team can help you identify homes that may be overpriced, overlooked, or ready for negotiation. We look at days on market, comparable sales, seller motivation, inspection strategy, and total cost of ownership — not just the list price.

Through our Lifetime Home Support™ model, our clients also receive support long after closing. That includes access to our Home Support Team Partners, trusted local service providers, moving perks, homeownership resources, and concierge-style guidance designed to help you maintain and enjoy your home for years to come.

Buying a home is not just about getting under contract. It is about making a smart move before, during, and forever.

Ready to Take the Next Step?

A house sitting on the market is not always a red flag. In today’s market, it may be one of your strongest opportunities to negotiate.

If you are buying a home in Sioux Falls, SD, do not just chase the newest listings. Look at the homes other buyers are skipping. That is often where the opportunity is hiding.

For help deciding which lingering listings are worth a second look, connect with Amy Stockberger Real Estate.

Our team is here to serve — before, during, and forever.

 

💬 Have more questions about selling your home in Sioux Falls, SD?
Ask our 24/7 Sioux Falls Real Estate Help Center AI Assistant