5 Home Upgrades That Pay Off When You Sell in Sioux Falls
Logo

All Around Surfaces

May 07, 2026

5 Home Upgrades That Pay Off When You Sell, and Why Epoxy Flooring Made Our List

 

Sioux Falls home with epoxy garage floor and updated finishes ready for sale

By Amy Stockberger
Founder of Amy Stockberger Real Estate.

Selling a home in Sioux Falls is different than selling almost anywhere else in the country. Our market moves fast. Buyers know what they want. Inventory is tight in most price ranges — and homes that show well, photograph well, and feel finished sell for top dollar.

After years of watching what works in this market, we have a short list of upgrades that consistently pay off when sellers invest in them before listing. Some are obvious. One is on the list for reasons most homeowners never consider.

The 5 Upgrades — At a Glance

1

Fresh Interior Paint — highest return per dollar

2

Kitchen Cabinet Refresh — transforms without a full remodel

3

Garage Floor Coating — the upgrade most sellers overlook

4

Basement Floor Finishing — unlocks perceived square footage

5

Front Door, Lighting & Curb Appeal — first impression wins


1

Fresh Interior Paint

Typical Cost

$2,500 – $6,000

Return at Sale

2–3x the investment

Buyers walk into a home and decide within 60 seconds whether the home feels finished or tired. Fresh paint in modern, neutral colors is the single highest-return upgrade you can make before listing. Greige, warm white, and soft natural tones work best in our market.

Skip bold accent walls and trendy colors. Buyers are not looking for a personality. They are looking for a blank slate they can imagine living in.


2

Kitchen Cabinet Refresh

Typical Cost

$3,000 – $15,000

Return at Sale

70–90% of cost

Full kitchen remodels rarely return their full cost at sale. Smart cabinet upgrades do. Painting existing cabinets in a modern color, replacing hardware, and updating lighting transforms a tired kitchen for a fraction of a full remodel cost.

Buyers in the $300,000+ range expect updated kitchens. Sellers who deliver get full asking and faster offers.


3

Garage Floor Coating

Most Overlooked Upgrade

Typical Cost

$1,500 – $4,000

Return at Sale

Often exceeds investment at $350K+

This is the upgrade most sellers overlook — and the one we recommend most often. A coated garage floor signals a finished, well-maintained home the moment a buyer pulls into the driveway. Bare gray concrete, or worse, a peeling paint job, signals deferred maintenance before anyone even walks inside.

Polyaspartic floor coatings install in a single day. The garage is walkable in 4 hours. Sellers can get this done in the final week before listing photos.

Our Recommended Partner

We send our clients to All Around Surfaces for these projects. Greg Muller and his team specialize in residential garage coatings, use commercial-grade polyurea and polyaspartic products, and back the work with a 50-year written warranty. Most coating companies offer 1 to 5 years — if anything at all.

The investment is small. The visual impact is immediate. The maintenance signal it sends to buyers is strong.


4

Basement Floor Finishing

Typical Cost

$2,000 – $8,000

Return at Sale

Strong with finished basement

A finished basement adds significant square footage in Sioux Falls homes — and buyers count every inch in their value calculation. The floor is the foundation of that finished space. A polished or coated basement floor instantly raises the perceived quality of the lower level and lets the home compete with newer construction.

If your basement is unfinished but the floor is clean and coated, buyers see possibility — not a project they have to take on themselves. We recommend All Around Surfaces for basement floor coating and polishing as part of pre-listing prep.


5

Front Door, Lighting & Curb Appeal

Typical Cost

$500 – $3,000

Return at Sale

100–200% of investment

The first photo on every listing is the front of the home. The first impression at a showing is the front porch. A new front door, modern outdoor lighting, fresh paint on the trim, and clean landscaping changes the entire feel of the property — in photos and in person.

This is one of the cheapest upgrades on the list and one of the most visible.


Why Epoxy Flooring Belongs on This List

Most resale lists focus on kitchens, bathrooms, and curb appeal. Garage and basement floor finishing rarely make the cut — even though both are visible to every buyer who walks through the home.

Three reasons we put epoxy flooring on our list:

The Price Is Low

A coated garage floor costs less than $2,000 in many cases — far less than a paint job, kitchen refresh, or new front door. The return-on-investment ratio is hard to beat.

The Visual Impact Is Immediate

A coated garage transforms the most-overlooked space in the home into something that looks finished, modern, and intentional. Buyers notice it — and they remember it.

The Signal to Buyers Is Strong

Coated floors say “this home was cared for” before a buyer ever walks inside. That signal carries through every other inspection point of the showing.


How Our Clients Get Started

Our team makes the introduction to our trusted Home Support Team partners as part of every listing prep conversation. For epoxy flooring, decorative concrete coating, or basement floor work, we connect you to All Around Surfaces directly.

Greg and his team handle the inspection, written quote, and full installation — with priority scheduling for Amy Stockberger Real Estate clients.


Frequently Asked Questions

Which home upgrade has the highest return at resale in Sioux Falls?

Fresh interior paint and curb appeal upgrades typically deliver the highest return per dollar invested in the Sioux Falls market. Garage floor coating and basement floor finishing are strong second-tier upgrades, particularly for homes priced $350,000 and above where buyer expectations are higher.

How long before listing should I complete pre-listing upgrades?

Most pre-listing upgrades should be completed at least 2 weeks before professional listing photos. Polyaspartic floor coatings install in a single day so the timeline is flexible — but earlier is always better to allow for scheduling and any touch-up work.

Does Amy Stockberger Real Estate help coordinate the upgrades?

Yes. Amy Stockberger Real Estate works with sellers throughout the pre-listing process and connects them directly to Home Support Team partners. All Around Surfaces, our recommended partner for epoxy and concrete coatings, handles inspections and quotes within 24 hours.

What does a typical pre-listing budget look like in Sioux Falls?

Budgets vary widely. Sellers in the $300,000 to $500,000 range often invest $5,000 to $15,000 in pre-listing upgrades and recover the investment plus a premium at sale. Higher-priced homes have higher pre-listing budgets and matching expectations from buyers.

How does the Lifetime Home Support program connect homeowners to trusted partners like All Around Surfaces?

The Lifetime Home Support program connects our clients to vetted local businesses for every homeowner need after closing. All Around Surfaces is one of our trusted Home Support Team partners for concrete coating, polishing, and restoration. Clients of Amy Stockberger Real Estate receive direct introductions and ongoing access to the full partner network as part of the Lifetime Home Support program.


Ready to Plan Your Pre-Listing Upgrades?

Thinking about selling in the next 12 months?

Start the pre-listing conversation now. Amy Stockberger Real Estate walks through your home, identifies the highest-return upgrades for your price range, and connects you to the right Home Support Team partners. For floor coating, call All Around Surfaces at (605) 777-0999.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *